Let’s be real: Hiring your first marketing professional can feel like you’re on a wild treasure hunt for a mythical creature. You might think you need a one-person powerhouse who can do it all—design your brand, write every piece of content, run entire marketing campaigns, manage PR, and probably juggle fire while doing it. But here’s the hard truth: Searching for this all-powerful, “do-it-all” marketing unicorn is a recipe for disaster, not success. So, how do you avoid the chaos of unrealistic expectations and make sure this hire works for everyone—without burning out your new team member or yourself? 

The secret? Forget the unicorn. Focus on finding someone who’s a great fit for where you are now—not where you fantasize you’ll be in 10 years. Let’s dive into how you can make this hire the smart, sustainable move that sets you up for success (and doesn’t end in a meltdown). Spoiler: It’s all about balance. 

2. Craft a Job Description That Reflects Reality (Not a Wish List)

Once you’ve zeroed in on what you actually need, it’s time to write the job description. But here’s the key: don’t write a laundry list of every wish you’ve ever had for a marketer. Focus on the essentials and leave room for flexibility. An overly specific job description can unintentionally turn away great candidates who might have the right skills but don’t check every box.

What to include:

• The job title: Let’s be honest—marketing titles are often broad, ambiguous, and rarely tell the full story of what the job entails. Titles like “Marketing Manager” or “Marketing Specialist” can be useful, but they’re not always accurate or specific. Marketing isn’t a field with clear-cut certifications or rigid qualifications like other industries. So, be clear about what the role will actually require—don’t let the title box you in or discourage strong candidates. If the scope of the role could evolve depending on experience, make that clear, too. Flexibility is key.
• Key responsibilities: Focus on the must-do tasks—what is absolutely critical for your firm right now? This should reflect reality, not an idealized version of what you wish the role could be. Staying open to growth is fine—if the person who fills the role ends up wearing more hats than expected, that’s okay as long as you’re communicating transparently from the start.
• Skills and experience: Avoid the temptation to make a laundry list of every skill you think you want. Focus on the skills that directly align with the firm’s needs right now (but allow some room for a candidate to grow into the role). Be honest about what’s critical and what’s a nice-to-have, but don’t scare away someone who might be just what you need.
• Autonomy and expectations: Be upfront about how much independence the marketer will have. Will they own projects from start to finish, or will they be expected to carry out pre-determined initiatives from the executive team? If there’s room for flexibility, say so! It’s important to set expectations clearly to avoid confusion down the line.

3. Perfect is the Enemy of Good

It’s tempting to search for someone with the perfect resume, but passion and attitude often matter more. Look for a marketer who believes in your firm’s mission and is eager to grow alongside you. Holding out for the “perfect” candidate will most likely hold you back from the progress you’re looking for.

Here’s what to focus on:

• Passion over perfection: Focus on finding someone who’s genuinely excited about your vision. Even if they don’t have all the experience, are they eager to take on new tasks and grow? Do they want to dive deeper into the industry or move into leadership roles as your firm expands? A candidate looking to grow in the same direction as your firm can foster much more powerful synergy and longevity.
• Cultural fit is key: Technical skills matter, but cultural alignment is crucial for long-term success. Do they embody your firm’s values, like integrity or collaboration? How do they approach team dynamics, and will their style mesh with your existing team? These qualities are integral for collaboration across your team (and in marketing—collaboration is a must).
• Experience meets flexibility: A perfect skill set is nice, but flexibility is even more valuable. Does this person show potential to adapt and learn on the job? Consider whether they’re willing to grow into the role as your firm evolves, whether that means taking on more responsibility or shifting focus. Ultimately, you want someone who is not afraid to try something new as the needs of your firm shift and grow. c
• Alignment with firm goals: Do they share your view on how marketing should work with sales? Are they excited about the type of growth you’re aiming for—whether it’s expanding your digital presence, leading campaigns, or managing a team in the future? Find someone who shares your vision.

4. Negotiate Terms That Don’t Make Them (Or You) Run for the Hills

When it comes time to discuss terms, the goal is to build a partnership that benefits both you and your new hire. It’s not about offering the lowest salary or squeezing the most out of your budget—it’s about creating a mutually respectful agreement where both sides feel valued and supported.

• Compensation and benefits: Offer a fair salary that reflects the value the candidate brings to the role. If your salary range is tight, consider supplementing with additional perks like flexible work hours, professional development opportunities, or a creative project budget. Don’t overlook longer-term compensation structures like performance bonuses, profit sharing, or stock options if those align with your firm’s goals. These incentives can motivate your new hire to go above and beyond while also ensuring they’re invested in the company’s future success.

• Set realistic expectations: Be clear about what success looks like in the role and don’t set up your new hire for failure with an impossible workload. Establishing achievable goals, clear timelines, and open communication from the start helps keep both sides satisfied. If the role evolves, be flexible enough to adjust expectations as necessary.
• Management and support structure: Define who will manage the new hire and how that relationship will work. Ensure there’s a clear support system in place, with regular check-ins and a process for feedback. This helps build trust and sets up your new hire for success in the long term.

5. Support Them with Onboarding That Doesn’t Feel Like a Drowning Exercise

Once you’ve made the hire, don’t just throw them into the deep end. Onboarding is your opportunity to set your new hire up for success. Provide a defined process with the tools, training, and support they need to thrive—and remember, starting small is perfectly okay.

• Define a structured onboarding and training process: A clear and well-thought-out onboarding plan is crucial. This includes introducing them to your firm’s culture, processes, and key stakeholders. Provide them with training on any tools or software they’ll be using, and make sure they understand your firm’s goals and values. A strong onboarding process sets the tone for a productive relationship.
• Ask them what they need: The best way to ensure they’re equipped for success is by asking. Don’t assume your new hire knows exactly what they need on day one. Have an open conversation about what resources or tools would help them do their job more effectively. Set up periodic check-ins to ensure they have what they need and provide the opportunity for feedback.
• Foster collaboration and accountability: Marketing can’t exist in a vacuum. Make sure your new hire knows who their key stakeholders are, both within and outside of the marketing team. Define how these stakeholders will collaborate with them and ensure everyone is held accountable. Set expectations for cross-department communication, and make sure there’s a process in place to track progress and address any roadblocks. Clear communication and collaboration will help marketing thrive and keep initiatives on track.
• Support work-life balance: It’s tempting to give a new hire a never-ending list of tasks, but that leads to burnout. Instead, work together to create a realistic timeline for deliverables and prioritize tasks. A balanced workload, combined with a supportive environment, will lead to long-term success for both your new hire and your firm. Happy marketers make for happy firms.

Make Sure an Internal Hire is the Right Move

If your reaction to the steps outlined about is “Wow I am nowhere close to having any of this established,” and internal hire might not be the right move for you today—and thats okay. A new hire (especially one that will kick off a brand new department) is a big commitment, so if the answer is unclear or you’re not ready to commit to a permanent role, consider external support as an alternative.

Hiring an agency, consultant, or freelancer can give you the marketing expertise you need without the long-term commitment of a full-time employee. These options are ideal for smaller firms or those still figuring out their marketing direction but needing help to get things off the ground.

External support can offer specialized skills—whether it’s content creation, SEO, or campaign management—without the overhead of a full-time hire. Plus, agencies and freelancers can help you develop your strategy and grow alongside your firm. So, if the thought of a permanent hire feels like too much right now, leveraging external support could be your best bet.

Conclusion: Progress, Not Perfection, Is the Goal

Hiring your first marketing professional doesn’t have to be about finding the perfect candidate who can do everything. It’s about making a realistic hire that aligns with your firm’s immediate needs and long-term goals—and, equally important, fostering a healthy, balanced work culture where everyone can thrive.

Remember, this isn’t about finding a unicorn who checks every box. It’s about building something that works for both your firm and your new hire. And if that sounds like too much, don’t hesitate to lean on outside help. Marketing is a journey, and finding the right path—whether through an internal hire or external support—will make all the difference.

Looking for more ways your team can collaborate and grow? Follow us on LinkedIn to stay in touch!