Mastering Retirement Plan Contributions: Common Pitfalls and Best Practices
Retirement plan contributions are a crucial part of any company’s benefit plan operation and managing them effectively can be a complex and overwhelming task. With intricate processes and numerous compliance requirements, errors can easily occur. This guide breaks down common pitfalls, explores how automation can simplify the process, and outlines best practices to ensure compliance and protect your employees’ financial futures.
Top Challenges in Retirement Plan Contributions

Missing Deferral Elections
One of the most frequent issues is missing an employee’s deferral election. This often happens due to miscommunication between HR and payroll systems or recordkeeping vendors when an employee makes a change or simply because a new enrollment was overlooked. When deferral elections aren’t implemented, employees miss out on valuable retirement savings, and companies face potential compliance penalties.
Late Contributions
The Department of Labor (DOL) mandates that employee contributions be deposited as soon as they can reasonably be segregated from the company’s general assets. For smaller plans (defined as fewer than 100 participants), this timeframe is typically seven business days. Delayed contributions can result in significant DOL penalties.
Incorrect Contribution Amounts
Errors in calculating contributions are surprisingly common. These often stem from payroll system inaccuracies or misunderstandings about what the plan document defines as “compensation.” Even minor miscalculations, when compounded, can lead to major compliance issues and financial repercussions for your company.
The Role of Automation in Reducing Errors
Automating payroll and retirement plan contributions can be transformative. By streamlining processes and reducing the risk of human error, automation helps ensure accuracy and timeliness. Here’s how:
- Automated Enrollment: Captures deferral elections accurately and implements them seamlessly. Knowing new hires will be automatically enrolled unless they opt out makes deferral elections predictable.
- System Integration: Links payroll and retirement plan systems to process contributions on time and accurately and feeding deferral elections and contributions seamlessly between your vendors.
- Compliance Checks: Flags potential issues in real-time, catching problems early and preventing costly errors. If you struggle with your own checks and balances, ask your providers what assistance they can provide to help ensure contributions are submitted timely and accurately.
By leveraging automation, companies can enhance efficiency while reducing compliance risks.
Consequences of Contribution Errors
Errors in retirement plan contributions can lead to significant financial and reputational consequences, including:
- DOL Penalties: For certain violations, penalties may amount to 20% of the transaction in question.
- IRS Penalties: Errors could jeopardize plan qualification status, resulting in costly corrective measures.
- Lost Employee Earnings: Missed or delayed contributions impact employees’ investment growth, potentially affecting their financial security.
Correction Programs: How to Recover from Mistakes
Mistakes happen, but correction programs can help companies address errors and stay compliant:
- IRS Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System (EPCRS): Allows companies to correct errors and avoid plan disqualification.
- DOL’s Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program (VFCP): Enables companies to self-correct fiduciary breaches, such as late contributions, mitigating penalties and restoring plan integrity.
Compliance Best Practices for Peace of Mind
Adopting these best practices can help your company minimize errors and ensure compliance:
- Regular Process Reviews: Routinely evaluate payroll and contribution processes to align with compliance standards.
- Conduct Audits: Perform periodic audits to identify and address errors early.
- Employee Training: Provide HR and payroll teams with ongoing training on retirement plan processes and current regulations.
- Implement Controls: Establish internal checks to catch errors at every stage, from deferral elections to contributions.
- Leverage Third-Party Expertise: Partner with a third-party administrator or advisor for specialized guidance and oversight.
A Roadmap to Compliance and Efficiency
By focusing on best practices, utilizing automation, and using correction programs when necessary, companies can reduce errors, avoid penalties, and ensure employees receive the full benefits of their retirement contributions. With the right approach, managing retirement plans can feel less like a chore and more like a streamlined, efficient process.
Ensure your retirement plan contributions are on track. Connect with a plan specialist to simplify your process and maximize compliance!
Categories
Recent Insights
-
Smart Starts: The Best Books and Games to Teach Kids About Money (Ages 4–12)
Why Teaching Financial Literacy to Kids Matters Financial literacy is one of the most important life skills we can teach children—and yet, it’s rarely part of the standard school curriculum. Left unaddressed, money can become a source of confusion or even anxiety later in life. But taught early, it becomes a tool for empowerment. The…
-
One Big Beautiful Bill: Key Financial Impacts for LGBTQIA+ Households
On July 4, 2025, President Donald Trump signed the “One Big Beautiful Bill Act” into law—a wide-reaching piece of legislation that touches everything from tax rates and healthcare to education, housing, and family benefits. For LGBTQIA+ individuals and families, some of these changes may create new planning opportunities, while others may require a closer look…
-
What’s a Trump Account? A New Way to Build Financial Discipline—From Day One
The Trump Account isn’t a flashy new savings tool. In fact, that’s its strength. It’s structured, restrictive, and deliberately focused—and in a world of financial products that promise flexibility and quick access, that kind of design is rare. But for families who value discipline, long-term thinking, and intentional planning, it might be exactly what you’ve…
-
How Microsoft Teams Can Transform Your RIA Firm’s Efficiency and Compliance
In the competitive world of registered investment advisory (RIA) firms, effective communication and collaboration are key to delivering exceptional client service and maintaining regulatory compliance. Before the pandemic, in-person collaboration was the norm at our firm, but with the transition to a fully remote office, we needed a secure internal communication platform. Today, as many…
-
One Big Beautiful Bill: How Trump’s Tax Overhaul Impacts American Families and Businesses
On July 4th, 2025, President Donald Trump signed into law the “One Big Beautiful Bill Act,” a sweeping piece of legislation that reshapes the American tax landscape and introduces a range of economic, social, and regulatory reforms. Below is an examination of the bill’s key provisions. Key Provisions of the “Big Beautiful Bill” 1. Permanent Extension and Expansion…