Financially Ever After? Exploring the Dollars and Cents of Marriage for Same-Sex Couples

Since the landmark 2015 Supreme Court decision legalizing same-sex marriage nationwide, LGBTQ couples have gained equal access to the financial benefits and considerations that come with marriage. However, the decision to marry involves complex financial implications that deserve careful consideration. Let’s explore whether it makes financial sense for same-sex couples to get married by examining the pros and cons.

The Financial Benefits of Marriage: More Than Just Love

Marriage provides numerous financial benefits, many of which are particularly attractive to same-sex couples who previously lacked access to these protections. From tax savings to legal advantages, marriage can create long-term financial security for couples.

Download our free guide on issues to consider when getting married.

Tax Pitfalls: Could the Marriage Penalty Affect You?

While the tax benefits of marriage can be substantial, it’s important to consider potential drawbacks as well. High-earning couples may face what’s known as the “marriage penalty,” where their combined incomes push them into higher tax brackets, resulting in a larger overall tax burden.

For example, if both partners earn a similar, high income, their combined earnings could move them into the 37% tax bracket, leading to increased tax liabilities. Certain deductions and credits phase out at higher income levels, which can affect couples with substantial combined incomes. This could potentially negate some of the tax benefits of marriage for high-earning couples.

For those with student loans on income-based repayment plans, filing jointly can increase reported income, potentially resulting in higher student loan payments. This is an important consideration for couples carrying significant educational debt.

Beyond Taxes: Legal and Financial Advantages of Marriage

Marriage offers several financial benefits beyond taxes that can make it an attractive option for same-sex couples. One significant advantage is access to Social Security benefits based on a spouse’s work history. This can provide valuable support during retirement or in the event of a spouse’s death.

Health insurance is another area where marriage can offer financial benefits. Many employers offer health insurance coverage for spouses, potentially reducing overall healthcare costs for the couple. Additionally, while some employers provide domestic partner benefits, spousal benefits are often more comprehensive.

Marriage also provides important legal protections for jointly owned property and simplifies estate planning processes. These legal safeguards can offer peace of mind and financial security for both partners.

Challenges of Combining Finances and Managing Debt

While the potential benefits of marriage are clear, couples should also consider how marriage might impact their overall financial picture. Marriage often involves combining finances and making joint decisions about budgeting, saving, and investing. This can be beneficial if both partners are aligned in their financial goals and habits, but it can also be challenging if there are significant differences in financial philosophies or practices.

Additionally, couples should understand that in many cases, spouses become jointly responsible for debts incurred during the marriage. This shared liability can have significant implications for both partners’ financial futures, especially if one partner enters the marriage with significant debt.

The Impact of Marriage on Education and Financial Aid

For couples with college-aged children, it’s important to consider how combined incomes might affect eligibility for financial aid. In some cases, marriage could reduce a student’s eligibility for need-based financial assistance. If you’re relying on financial aid for educational expenses, this is a crucial consideration when evaluating whether marriage makes financial sense.

Does Marriage Make Financial Sense for You?

The answer to whether marriage makes financial sense for same-sex couples isn’t a simple yes or no. It depends on each couple’s unique financial situation, income levels, long-term goals, and personal circumstances.

For many couples, the tax benefits, legal protections, and access to spousal benefits make marriage a financially advantageous choice. This is particularly true for couples with disparate incomes, where joint filing can result in significant tax savings, or for those concerned about estate planning and ensuring their partner is provided for in the event of their death.

However, for high-earning couples, those with significant student loan debt, or partners who prefer to keep their finances separate, the financial benefits of marriage may be less clear-cut. In these cases, it’s crucial to carefully weigh the potential advantages against the drawbacks.

Steps to Ensure a Financially Sound Marriage

If you’re considering marriage, there are several steps you can take to ensure you’re making a financially sound decision:

1. Have open and honest discussions about your financial situations, goals, and concerns.
2. Review and update beneficiary designations on retirement accounts, insurance policies, and other financial documents.
3. Consider a prenuptial agreement to protect individual assets and clarify financial responsibilities.
4. Seek professional advice from a financial advisor and tax professional to navigate the complexities of marriage and make informed decisions.

While marriage can offer significant financial benefits for same-sex couples, it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. By carefully considering both the advantages and potential drawbacks, and seeking professional guidance when needed, couples can make informed decisions that support their long-term financial well-being and relationship goals.

Considering marriage and how it will impact your finances?

Connect with an advisor to explore personalized financial advice for you and your partner.